David Oliver reports on the need for increased numbers of specialist palliative care doctors and nurses as well as an improvement in confidence and skill of newly qualified doctors in palliative care.
Read Professor David Oliver’s perspective in the BMJ this week. Prof. Oliver, consultant in geriatric medicine and acute general medicine, reports on the recent Royal College of Physicians audit on end of life care in hospitals. It concludes there is not only need for increased numbers of specialist palliative care doctors and nurses but a continuing need to improve the confidence and skill of newly qualified doctors in palliative care.
This clearly resonates with the aims of PATCH and a number of our recently funded projects, such as the development of an App to help doctors convert from one painkiller to another, and a project in preparation to develop a short training course for nurses working in the acute sector – a joint hospice and hospital initiative based by the bedside and concentrating on issues specific to a busy acute setting.
David Oliver: End of life care in hospital is everyone’s business
Palliative care: do we need more specialist clinicians, or more generalist staff better trained in it? My answer is both.
About 500 000 people die each year in England and Wales. Yet the United Kingdom has only an estimated 519 specialist palliative medicine consultants and fewer than 5000 crucial specialist palliative care nurses.
A national audit of end of life care in hospital by the Royal College of Physicians found a median of one palliative medicine consultant and five nurse specialists for every 1000 adult hospital beds.
Some of us will die suddenly. Others may have only weeks to prepare after an unexpected terminal diagnosis, but most will die with or from long term conditions. Multiple contacts with health and care practitioners give us many opportunities to discuss and plan for our deaths.
Despite concerted campaigns to improve care in the last year of life and get more people to make advance plans, these opportunities are missed. Only 4% of 9000 patients in the hospital audit had any form of advance plan made before admission.
Nearly half of us die in hospital.6 We don’t have sufficient hospice places, staff, or funding to support everyone to die in other settings. Some people may wish to stay in hospital at the end, and a death in hospital need not be a bad one. We have—in the words of one campaign—“one chance to get it right.” And, despite very poor experiences reported by, for instance, the NHS Ombudsman, we seem to get it right more often than not.
The latest national survey found that two thirds of 21 000 bereaved people thought that the quality of care had been outstanding, excellent, or good, although one in 10 rated it as poor. Hospices offered the best experience overall, and symptom control was easier to achieve in hospital than at home.
Many recently qualified doctors report feeling underprepared for end of life care
However, the Royal College of Physicians audit found major gaps in documenting basic aspects of care in patients whose death could reasonably be anticipated. These included patients or loved ones discussing their own concerns and choices; spiritual care; clear plans around eating, drinking, artificial nutrition, and hydration; and control of common symptoms. Only a third of hospitals had face to face specialist palliative care seven days a week. Many patients were unable to see specialist doctors or nurses.
Many recently qualified doctors report feeling underprepared for end of life care. The National Council for Palliative Care and Marie Curie have highlighted similar training gaps among nurses.
Without substantial and un-promised increases in staff numbers in specialist palliative medicine and nursing, getting the basics right must be everyone’s business.